Following the cancellation of the show, many fans took to their social media to post their reaction.
One fan wrote,
"What?! Wow. A highly underrated show that deserved a lot more publicity. Terrifically fun, checks all the genre boxes, some very gritty action, and great characterization! Shared with friends who loved it. Assume the show is a casualty of COVID cutbacks. Frustrating! [Prime Video]."
Another fan wrote,
"High Sierra Man I just got a new conspiracy theory as an early Christmas present. The Man canceled Utopia because it was getting too close to the truth! Pass it on!!!!"
The next fan wrote,
"You picked a hell of a place to quit! If this isn't the right time for the show, finish shooting it and release it when the time is right, but don't leave it unfinished! (I know, I don't have to pay for the production)."